Challenging Spousal Support: Legal Grounds and Considerations

Spousal support, also known as maintenance or alimony, is a financial obligation established during divorce proceedings to assist the lower-earning spouse in maintaining a standard of living similar to that experienced during the marriage. However, circumstances can evolve post-divorce, prompting one party to seek modification or termination of the spousal support order. Understanding the legal grounds and considerations for challenging spousal support in Illinois is essential for those seeking adjustments to their obligations.​ 

Grounds for Modifying or Terminating Spousal Support in Illinois

Illinois law permits modifications or terminations of spousal maintenance under specific conditions, primarily when a substantial change in circumstances occurs. The Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act outlines these provisions, emphasizing that modifications are contingent upon significant alterations in the financial or personal situations of either party. ​ 

  1. Substantial Change in Financial Circumstances

A significant shift in the financial status of either the paying or receiving spouse can justify a modification of spousal support. Such changes may include:​ 

  • Employment Status Changes: If the paying spouse loses their job or experiences a substantial reduction in income, they may petition the court to lower maintenance payments. Conversely, if the receiving spouse gains employment with a considerable salary, the paying spouse might seek a reduction. It’s crucial that employment changes are made in good faith; quitting a job solely to reduce support payments is generally not viewed favorably by the court. ​ 
  • Efforts Towards Self-Sufficiency: Courts expect the recipient spouse to make reasonable efforts to become financially independent. Demonstrating active job search efforts, acquiring new skills, or obtaining employment can influence the court’s decision regarding maintenance modifications. 
  • Health Impairments: Serious health issues affecting either spouse that impede their ability to work can lead to a modification. For instance, if a paying spouse develops a debilitating condition that limits their earning capacity, they may request a reduction in maintenance obligations. ​ 
  1. Cohabitation of the Recipient Spouse

In Illinois, maintenance obligations can be terminated if the recipient spouse begins cohabiting with a romantic partner on a resident, continuing conjugal basis. Cohabitation implies living together in a relationship akin to marriage. To modify spousal maintenance due to cohabitation, the paying spouse must typically demonstrate a substantial change in circumstances, which, in this case, is the cohabitation itself. Evidence such as shared financial accounts, joint leases, or testimonies about the nature of the relationship may be presented to support the claim. ​ 

  1. Remarriage of the Recipient Spouse

The remarriage of the spouse receiving maintenance automatically terminates the obligation to pay spousal support in Illinois. The recipient is required to notify the paying spouse at least 30 days before the marriage. Failure to provide this notice can lead to complications, including the potential need to repay maintenance payments made after the remarriage. ​ 

  1. Death of Either Party

Spousal maintenance obligations cease upon the death of either the paying or receiving spouse. The decedent’s estate is not responsible for continuing maintenance payments. If payments are made after the death of the recipient, the estate must repay the payer. ​ 

Legal Process for Modifying or Terminating Maintenance

To initiate a modification or termination of spousal support, the concerned party must file a motion with the court that issued the original maintenance order. This motion should detail the substantial change in circumstances justifying the requested adjustment. It’s important to note that maintenance payments continue as ordered until the court modifies or terminates the obligation.​ 

Considerations for Challenging Spousal Support

When contemplating challenging spousal support, several factors should be considered:

  • Burden of Proof: The party seeking modification or termination carries the burden of proving that a substantial change in circumstances has occurred. This requires presenting compelling evidence to the court.​
  • Good Faith Actions: Changes in employment or financial status must be made in good faith. Actions perceived as attempts to evade support obligations may not be favorably viewed by the court.​ 
  • Legal Representation: Navigating the complexities of spousal support modifications necessitates experienced legal counsel. An attorney specializing in family law can provide guidance tailored to the specific circumstances of the case.​

Conclusion

Challenging spousal support in Illinois involves demonstrating substantial changes in circumstances, such as significant shifts in financial status, cohabitation, remarriage, or death. Given the complexities of family law, consulting with legal professionals is advisable to effectively navigate the process. At Anderson Boback & Marshall, our Chicago spousal support lawyer is committed to providing expert legal assistance tailored to your unique situation. If you’re considering modifying or terminating spousal support, contact us today to schedule a consultation and discuss your options.​